Cinema Monolith

Reviews of movies from my giant DVD tower, and more.

The Fan

The FanCinema Monolith: 4/10 This film is part of the Cinema Monolith collection!
IMDb: 5.8/10
Leonard Maltin’s Movie Guide: *½ out of 4

Released on August 19, 1996
Rated R
116 minutes

Directed by Tony Scott

Written by Phoef Sutton, based on the novel by Peter Abrahams

Cast: Robert De Niro, Wesley Snipes, Ellen Barkin, John Leguizamo, Benicio Del Toro, Patti D’Arbanville, Chris Mulkey, Dan Butler, Kurt Fuller, M.C.Gainey, Jack Black, Don S. Davis, Charles Hallahan, Frank Medrano, John Kruk

Have you ever made it a point to steer clear of a particular movie simply because it contained a scene or situation that was so patently ridiculous, watching it would serve no purpose but to drive another nail into the coffin of common sense filmmaking? For me, that movie was The Fan, which I’d staunchly avoided until, after nearly twenty years, the urge to witness for myself its much-discussed (and much-derided) conclusion got the best of me. And so I recently sat down and watched with incredulous eyes as my worst fears were realized, and a professional baseball game was played smack-dab in the middle of a torrential downpour.

Granted, it would be different if this were a comedy about a small town softball game, where for comedic purposes the umps allowed the teams to play through a rainstorm or blizzard or locust swarm, but it wasn’t. This was a serious psychological thriller, with Robert De Niro cast as a dyed-in-the-wool San Francisco Giants fan who’s more than ecstatic when his team signs a Barry Bonds-like superstar, but who soon goes off the deep end when the player doesn’t live up to his hype, or his forty million dollar paycheck. And with major league baseball as a backdrop, the rules of major league baseball should apply…especially when one of those rules demands a game be stopped when it rains!

Mind you, I’m not saying the film was all bad. In fact, at the start things were headed in a decent direction, with both De Niro and Wesley Snipes convincing in their roles as fan and player, and an interesting story developing between the two that hinted to parallel problems in their lives, which in a different movie would have them bonding instead of trying to kill each other. I especially liked De Niro early on, before he went full-bore psychotic and became a caricature; he was definitely troubled, but to some extent you sympathized with him, and couldn’t help but blame the rotten people around him—his ex-wife, his boss, his clients—for pushing him to the brink.

But then, there was the rain sequence. Apparently, during filming of these scenes, everyone on-set tried to convince director Tony Scott that baseball games, professional or otherwise, were never played in a heavy rain. Ever. And for whatever reason, Scott ignored this sage advice, and filmed the scenes in hurricane-like conditions anyway: the field was a swamp, the basepaths were nothing but lakes of mud, and the players were so hopelessly drenched, they were probably carrying an extra twenty pounds of wet in their uniforms. It was as unbelievable as anything I’ve ever seen in film, and not only was it laughable, but nothing short of stupid as well.

And that wasn’t the end of it. Along with the outright dismissal of a host of other rules and conventions of modern baseball, including but not limited to players coming off the bench to bat (instead of from the on-deck circle), playing home games in road uniforms, and having grand slams hit with just one man on base, the film offered another twist that was so head-shakingly absurd, I can’t help but spoil it for you. Ready? During a climactic attempt at an inside-the-park home run, which would decide whether Snipes’ son lives or dies (don’t ask), it’s discovered that…De Niro’s character is now the home plate umpire! Gaaaaadzooks! I sure didn’t see that one coming!

As thrillers go, I’d say The Fan was merely routine, but if you’re a fan of De Niro you might enjoy watching him re-visit Taxi Driver territory again; his sudden left turn from troubled to totally unhinged seemed a bit out of place, but otherwise he was still a fun watch, as always. However, as a baseball-themed offering, this one definitely misses the mark, and loses points for the filmmakers’ shameful disregard for authenticity. Trust me, there are better De Niro films and better baseball movies out there to spend an evening with…although if your only other choices are The Adventures of Rocky & Bullwinkle and Here Come the Tigers, then I’d recommend sticking with this one.  (4/10)

The Fan - photo final

12 comments on “The Fan

  1. grandrapidsgirl

    How totally bizarre! Think I’ll steer clear, but thanks for the excellent commentary! I guess De Niro’s a little further from perfect with this.


    • Todd Benefiel

      He’s not bad, but I never did buy into his total disintegration from average pissed-off guy to extreme lunatic. Maybe it’s because I’ve never considered De Niro or his characters to be lunatics…or maybe it was just poor writing! Thanks for swinging by, Julie, and I hope you’re wrapping up your weekend on a good note!


  2. Stu

    I’ve never actually seen this, although I do remember the trailer, oddly enough. I think every time I’ve seen De Niro play a psycho (or even someone with slightly intimidating or oddball tendencies) post-Cape Fear I always wish I was watching something like Taxi Driver or The King Of Comedy instead.

    And what kind of pampered, over-paid namby-pambies refuse to play baseball in the rain?


    • Todd Benefiel

      That’s funny…towards the end of The Fan I was thinking about watching Taxi Driver again, just so I could see De Niro do ‘psycho’ right! And like The Fan, I stayed away from The King of Comedy because of one detrimental (to me) aspect of it: Jerry Lewis. I guess now I’ll add that one AND Donnie Darko to my list!

      And to answer your question: all of them!


    • Tyson Carter

      Ignore Todd, this film is great!! I loved it, and with some Rolling Stones music included its a great time 🙂


      • Todd Benefiel

        You loved it? Oh, you and your De Niro fetish! Thank heavens he wasn’t in Howard the Duck or you’d be slobbering all over that movie, too!

        Liked by 1 person

      • Stu

        Tyson – between you and me I ignore pretty much everything that Todd says about movies. (I’m pretty sure he’s not reading these comments.)

        Liked by 1 person

      • Todd Benefiel

        Hi, Irving here, from the Cinema Monolith Legal Department. Mr. Benefiel has been notified of your comments, and wants me to pass along that any more slander directed at him or his site – especially from someone who doesn’t understand The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai – will be met with harsh and perhaps demoralizing comebacks. Thank you.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Tyson Carter

        Best way to do things Stu 😉

        And yeah Todd, check out my review, really enjoy this movie 🙂


      • Todd Benefiel

        Just checked out your review, Tyson, and it looks like we both agree that De Niro is the high point of the film…and yes, you most definitely liked it better overall than I did! A good review, though…I enjoyed that. And by the way, my legal team is preparing an injunction against you and Stu as we speak.


  3. spreth1

    OK, my questions are more about the facts than the review . . . I’m struggling with “Bobby Bonds – like”, “superstar” and “forty million paycheck”. Bobby’s 1977 salary is listed a mere $175,000. Was Bonds your favorite player when you were growing up, so through your “Ruppert Jones”-tinged glasses, Bonds is a superstar? In regard to the review, this is again some really great writing, but you don’t need me hurling plaudits in your direction, I’m sure.


    • Todd Benefiel

      Well, having two blog sites running at the same time, and one being a site centered on the 1978 baseball season, I should be excused for writing ‘Bobby’ instead of ‘Barry’! Thanks for the spotting that…I’ll fix it now, but I just remembered, I think I put it there on purpose, so people could have fun playing the ‘spot the mistake’ game. And thanks for the compliment, but I’d rather you didn’t do any hurling at all, if that’s okay.

      And wait…Ruppert Jones NOT a superstar? What notebook is he in then?


Feel free to comment, you readers of the Monolith!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address and click the button below to become a bona fide Cinema Monolith follower. C'mon, what's the worst that could happen?

Join 204 other followers

Review Totals

Movies Reviewed: 227

From the Monolith: 125

Movies by Decade

1920s – 0
1930s – 6
1940s – 19
1950s – 37
1960s – 34
1970s – 36
1980s – 35
1990s – 6
2000s – 13
2010s – 41

Movies by Genre

Action/Adventure – 42
Comedy – 35
Crime – 22
Documentary – 5
Drama – 26
Horror – 38
Musical – 1
Mystery/Thriller – 19
Romance – 3
Sci-Fi/Fantasy – 27
Western – 8

Movies by CM Rating

10 star – 10
9 star – 28
8 star – 36
7 star – 31
6 star – 22
5 star – 23
4 star – 24
3 star – 18
2 star – 20
1 star – 12
0 star – 3

Movies by MPAA Rating

Pre-1968 – 91
G – 1
PG – 32
PG-13 – 34
R – 60
NC-17 – 0
TV and Unrated – 9

Blogathons I’ve Joined

The Coolest Links

This review has been approved by Team Banzai!
%d bloggers like this: